@Thunder240 - Here are my observations and my own dilemma regarding the topic. Maybe it helps? I dunno.
I noticed a correlation between how Lawton categorizes the differences in his little sound circle as being warm and rich through clean and focused - type 1 through 5 - to the hardness of the woods used for each type. Type 1 woods are the softest, and 5 the hardest.
Type 1 - Mahogany and walnut. Janka hardness around 1000.
Type 2 & 3 - Maple, padauk, sapele, and koa. Around 1300-1600.
Type 4 - Rosewood and bubinga. Janka north of 1500.
Type 5 - Bocote, bloodwood, ebony. All severely dense and hard. Janka north of 2200.
My question to Mark Lawton would be: how much of the described sound differences between types is discernable in practice? Are we talking a 3 to 6% difference? 10 - 20%? Can I make a piercingly bright headphone seem dark? His marketing material seems to make it seem that way, and I don’t quite buy into it.
I’m not saying he is trying to mislead people, it’s just that audiophile terms are by and large crap. So are people’s descriptions of stuff when they’re trying to make a buck. (I’m more of a skeptic than a cynic, honestly!) That last bit applies to all markets, not just headphones. Anyway, I digress…
I am more inclined to believe that the damping and shape of the cup will affect tone and frequency response more than the wood will. In the world of ZMF, density of the wood affects decay and speed in slightly noticeable amounts, while the tone and frequency response is nearly always the same regardless of wood.
The TH-X line is NOT that way, however, as the TH-X00 ebony, purpleheart, and mahogany all have different bass and treble quantity. Measurably different. So… I’m at a loss. My experience with different wood on one headphone doesn’t seem to correlate to different wood on another. I don’t know what to think.
That’s half the reason why I’ve been super curious about the Lawton mods, but never pulled the trigger. I just have no idea what I’m actually going to be getting. I don’t like that.
Besides, the Teak + ZMF Univ Suede pads are nearly perfect to me, and I already own that, so why mess with it, ya?
If I were to offer any advice, I would say email Mark. See what he says. lawtonaudio@gmail.com I’ve contacted him a few times and he seems like a straight shooter.