Re-Discovering the joys of optical media

Lately, have started to listen to my optical media collection more and streaming less. I had forgotten just how good a CD disc can sound. It’s nice to listen to an entire album and get the feel of what the artist(s) were trying to achieve.

For whatever reason, the sound from the optical media seems to be a tad more open/alive sounding than the streaming services. Not sure why this is, but it could be the difference in source material.

At any rate, it’s been fun to enjoy music with hard media again vice streaming.

4 Likes

See if you can compare CDs to streams with the same master. To the extent there is a difference, it is likely in different masters.

I’ve also been getting back into CDs. I pay more attention when I put on vinyl or load a CD.

1 Like

The data stored on a CD-DA is 16-bit/44.1 kHz PCM, so it’s not fundamentally different from what lossless streaming services provide. If you’re only noticing this with certain tracks, it could simply be because they were mixed or mastered differently. Or perhaps some of the enjoyment comes from the tactile experience of actually handling a physical medium—much like with vinyl!

Mixing/Mastering differences are one source of noticeable differences. Using TIDAL for streaming, which is pretty good overall.

Using a Audiolab 9000cdt for CD source, which goes to a Topping D900/A900, or to a Cenever ZeroUno DAC/HPA. One item I find interesting is that TIDAL has not removed the MQA files in their library. The Canever ZeroUno DAC has a excellent MQA decoder built in, and there are still quite a number of files that enable the green or blue MQA light.

That’s an interesting setup, and the transport/DAC combinations could definitely make the “sit down and listen” experience feel different even if the bits are notionally comparable. The mastering point is probably the big one, but I also wouldn’t discount how much the playback chain and the lack of app/device distractions change the perception.

On TIDAL/MQA, yeah, there still seem to be some MQA versions floating around depending on album/label/region and what the app serves up. If your DAC is lighting up green/blue, it’s clearly seeing an MQA-flagged stream. It’d be fun to pick a few albums where you own the CD and TIDAL has both versions, then compare CD vs FLAC vs MQA through the same DAC path.

1 Like