[Primary daily drivers:
Over-the-Ear Open-Back: Sennheiser HD800.
IEM: 64 Audio U12T.]
These are a NON-RETURNABLE FINAL SALE!
I recommend to AVOID PURCHASING THESE, unless one auditions them thoroughly first, sampling all of one’s preferred music genres and listening preferences, making sure, experientially, that this potentially deal-breaking issue, described below, indeed remains only a theoretical potential and, for oneself, never becomes an actualized experience.
There is much I could share about how good these headphones are in so many ways but none of the good that I could share here has not been shared by many already - my experience is in line with how these are raved about (though s more spacious soundstage would have been better).
Why the brutal rating? - This is the only thing I really want to share here - that, at least for me, the CLIPPING issue these have is an unbearable experience. It is such that it seemed obvious to me that these were simply defective… But, googling this quickly made me aware that this was not the case - this is a known condition that is not even considered to be as serious of a problem, being claimed by Focal that it is “intentionally so, by design, whenever the volume / bass is too high”.
My hearing is not impaired - it is absolutely normal, my lossless music library is just fine too, and in 95% of my listening time I would experience no clipping just because I would, naturally, not listen loud or want to boost the bass. But, sometimes, consciously so, I want to be able to listen loud enough to music which is more energetic and bass heavy (think Pixies, for example, or even tracks like some Billie Eilish’s songs, not that intense, which are recorded with a relatively high bass response to begin with) and just get wild for a little while (I do not want my hearing to become impaired either) - with these it is not always enabled… And I am not talking about some crazy powerful amp - plugging these into my little portable battery operated iFi Hip Dac, dialing it up all the way, yet still in the lower power mode, without even switching to the higher gain mode (the ‘PowerMatch’ button), it begins to kick in a little already; pressing the Bass Boost (‘XBass’ button) to somehow bypass the need to raise the volume of the whole, yet to increase it in the lower range for a stronger bass impact at an overall lower volume, and it is a full-on non-stop clipping which feels like an UNBEARABLE AUDIOPHILE’S HELL. Of all the headphones that I have had or listened to, I have never experienced anything as frustrating as this… Sure, many were flawed in one way or another, but this is on a whole different level.
Initially, I was struggling to just believe that this is actually how it is formally excused - a $1K headphones justified to be so - ‘by design’ - it felt to me completely unacceptable… I contacted Focal and received a long and detailed reply:
“There is no ‘Design Flaw’ but rather Design Choices, made by music maniacs who wanted to improve on the poor state of the current offerings in headphones.
You would never accept to have high end home speakers that would compress the dynamics of your music and yet you appear to accept that from headphones ?
What you are experiencing is quite normal for Focal headphones.
The Clears were developed to attain something that very few if any other brands try to do with headphones : getting the widest possible dynamic range, in respect with the emotion of music.
Most other brands use compression, meaning that there is less difference in volume between the quietest and the loudest passages.
They just make their units play as loud as they can.
Focal opted to go for full dynamics instead, just like a normal loudspeaker, so the quieter passages are quieter on a Focal than they usually are on other brands, but they will ‘explode’ to higher volumes extremely rapidly, following the dynamics of music.
If you listen to a lot of music that uses little or no compression, like Classical for instance, you will note a huge variation in volume.
Having been previously used to other types of headphones, you may tend to push the volume louder at first, in order to hear the quieter passages more easily, but when a solid Bass impact suddenly shows up, it may overload the unit.
… I encourage you to use them in the manner that they were designed for… You will find that they are capable of extraordinary ‘real’ performance.”
I found this explanation to be revealing and helpful - it did change the way I perceive this condition - and yes, for some listeners, under some circumstances (limited volume and bass shelf), this might be a positive design choice by a manufacturer and a satisfactory experience for a listener (the Clear is indeed outstanding in its dynamic range, the sense of speakers-like physicality and the feeling enabled by that).
I believe that Focal’s choice is a legitimate one, but there is ONE MAJOR PROBLEM which remains unchanged - not all listeners fall into this category… And as Focal was proud to claim - theirs is the ‘abnormal’ (statistically speaking) choice - there is no reason to expect even an audiophile with a decades long experience with many headphones, to anticipate ending up hearing these clipping noises - in this regard, it is literally unlike virtually all other non-Focal headphones one might have experienced, and naturally unpredictable.
I still believe that IT IS NOT RIGHT to have it offered for sale, WITHOUT AN EXPLICIT FACTUAL DISCLAIMER, in order to enable a potential customer, in the process of purchasing, the so-called right of an ‘informed consent’ (again, for the good and for the bad, this experience seems to be unique to Focal - I have never had it with any other brand/model before, and it cannot be predicted by customers). Otherwise, we end up in a potentially unpleasant situation, which is a hassle for all involved - Focal as the manufacturer, Headphones.com as the dealer, and obviously some customers, for whom there is also a significant financial loss involved.
This review is motivated by a wish to inform those readers for whom these headphones might not be the right choice, so that they do not need to end up in a situation similar to the one I am in.